Big Cartel vs Build My Stores
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Big Cartel is an e-commerce platform built specifically for independent artists, musicians, jewelry makers, illustrators, and small creative businesses who want to sell online without dealing with complicated setup. Stores can be built from customizable templates with no coding required, and sellers can list physical goods, digital downloads, and print-on-demand products. Beyond the storefront, Big Cartel supports multi-channel selling through Instagram, Facebook, and Google Shopping, along with built-in analytics, inventory tracking, and marketing tools like discount codes and early access drops. The platform positions itself as a low-commitment alternative to larger e-commerce suites, with flexible monthly plans and no long-term contracts.
Build My Stores is a platform for creating and managing online stores. It provides tools for building e-commerce websites, with features such as store setup, product management, and promotional communications. The platform appears to offer a sign-up and login interface for users to access their store-building dashboard.
- Purpose-built for artists and makers rather than generic retail
- Low monthly cost compared to larger e-commerce platforms
- No long-term contracts and easy plan cancellation
- Simple setup that does not require design or coding skills
- Easy store setup and management
- Built-in promotional tools and SMS alerts
- Supports multiple countries and phone numbers
- Fewer built-in apps and integrations than large platforms like Shopify
- Free plan is limited in product count and features
- Less suited to high-volume or complex B2B selling operations
- Requires account creation to access features
- May require CAPTCHA verification
- Limited information available without logging in
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Big Cartel
View all →
Alternatives to Build My Stores
View all →
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataBuild My Stores offers a simple, multi‑country web store with basic promotional tools, while Big Cartel provides richer features, templates and integrations aimed at artists and makers.
Key differences
- •Build My Stores requires account creation and phone verification; Big Cartel has a freemium sign‑up with no immediate verification.
- •Big Cartel includes ready‑made templates, digital/download sales, and multi‑channel sync; Build My Stores only lists store creation and SMS/email alerts.
- •Integrations: Big Cartel lists Shopify, Etsy, Squarespace, Instagram, Facebook, Google Shopping, Zapier; Build My Stores lists none.
- •Pricing: Build My Stores price is unknown; Big Cartel offers a free tier and clear paid plans.
- •Support: Build My Stores advertises multi‑country phone support; Big Cartel’s priority human support is limited to its highest‑tier plan.
Pricing & value
Big Cartel provides a freemium tier and disclosed pricing; Build My Stores price is unknown.
Ease of use / learning curve
Big Cartel offers template‑based setup with no coding; Build My Stores requires account, phone, and possible CAPTCHA.
Features & depth
Big Cartel includes digital goods, print‑on‑demand, abandoned cart recovery, and analytics; Build My Stores lists only basic store tools and alerts.
Integrations & ecosystem
Big Cartel lists integrations with Shopify, Etsy, Squarespace, social platforms, and Zapier; Build My Stores lists none.
Support
Build My Stores offers multi‑country phone support; Big Cartel’s priority human support is only on the Diamond plan.
Scalability
Big Cartel’s higher tiers add abandoned‑cart recovery and more products; Build My Stores provides no scalability details.
Security & privacy
Both require email/password sign‑up; no further security details are provided for either.
Choose Big Cartel if…
Artists, makers, or small creators wanting templates, digital/print‑on‑demand sales, and social‑media integrations.
Choose Build My Stores if…
Entrepreneurs needing a simple web store with phone‑based support across several countries.
Common questions
Is there a free or low‑cost option to start?
Big Cartel offers a freemium plan; Build My Stores pricing is not disclosed.
Can I sell digital downloads or print‑on‑demand items?
Yes, Big Cartel supports digital and print‑on‑demand; Build My Stores does not mention these capabilities.
What support is available if I need help?
Build My Stores provides multi‑country phone support; Big Cartel’s priority human support is only on its Diamond (highest‑paid) plan.