FindAlternative
Back to Borderlands 2

Borderlands 2 vs Payday 2

Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.

Compare
Borderlands 2
Borderlands 2Loot, shoot, and laugh through a chaotic sci‑fi adventure.
Payday 2
Payday 2An action-packed, four-player co-op shooter about epic heists in Washington D.C.
Overview
Description

Borderlands 2 drops players into the lawless world of Pandora, where they hunt for treasure, battle ruthless bandits, and uncover the secrets of the alien vaults. With its signature cel‑shaded art style and dark humor, the game blends fast‑paced shooting with deep RPG progression. Team up with friends in co‑op mode or go solo to experience a sprawling open world filled with procedurally generated loot, diverse skill trees, and endless side quests. The game’s replayability is driven by its massive arsenal of weapons and the ever‑changing challenges that keep each playthrough fresh.

Payday 2 is an action-packed, four-player co-op shooter that once again lets gamers don the masks of the original crew: Dallas, Hoxton, Wolf and Chains as they descend on Washington D.C. for an epic crime spree. Two years after the events of the first game, the Payday gang relocates to Washington, D.C. to carry out a new wave of heists, working through complex contracts from freeing arrested members to uncovering massive conspiracies.

Pricing
Paid (One-time)
Paid (One-time)
Category
First-Person Shooters
Co-op Shooters
Best for
Fans of looter‑shooters and cooperative action games
Co-op shooter fans and tactical gamers
Specifications
General
msrp
$39.99
$19.99−50%
release date
2012-09-18
2013-08-13
Specifications
developer
Gearbox Software
Overkill Software
publisher
2K Games, Sony Computer Entertainment of America, Aspyr Media
Starbreeze Studios, 505 Games+25150%
age rating
ESRB M, PEGI 18
PEGI 18, ESRB M
multiplayer
Single player, Multiplayer, Co-operative, Split screen
Single player, Multiplayer, Co-operative
critic score
81/100+8%
75/100
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • Massive variety of weapons keeps combat fresh.
  • Deep character customization with three skill trees per class.
  • Highly replayable co‑op experience.
  • Sharp humor and distinctive art style.
  • Engaging four-player cooperative gameplay
  • Deep character progression and weapon customization
  • Wide variety of heists and tactical approaches
  • Rich narrative campaign spanning multiple DLCs and updates
Cons
  • Performance can suffer on older consoles.
  • Random loot system may feel grind‑heavy for some players.
  • Story pacing can be uneven with frequent side‑quest interruptions.
  • Can be difficult for solo players without a dedicated team
  • Steep learning curve for complex stealth missions
  • Older game engine can feel dated compared to modern shooters
Community & Metrics
Upvotes
0
0
User rating
Not enough data
Not enough data

More alternatives & similar tools

Alternatives to Borderlands 2

View all →
Jak II
Jak II

Join Jak and Daxter in a gritty, open-world sci-fi adventure filled with intense action and shooter gameplay.

Compare
Payday: The Heist
Payday: The Heist

Team up for high‑octane heists in a fast‑paced shooter.

Compare
Borderlands
Borderlands

A chaotic loot‑filled shooter where every gun is unique

Compare
TimeSplitters 2
TimeSplitters 2

A thrilling first-person shooter spanning multiple eras to retrieve stolen Time Crystals.

Compare

Alternatives to Payday 2

View all →
Borderlands 2
Borderlands 2

Loot, shoot, and laugh through a chaotic sci‑fi adventure.

Compare
Voyeur II
Voyeur II

Uncover political corruption and blackmail in this FMV thriller sequel.

Compare
Payday: The Heist
Payday: The Heist

Team up for high‑octane heists in a fast‑paced shooter.

Compare
Left 4 Dead 2
Left 4 Dead 2

Co‑op zombie survival shooter that pits you against relentless hordes in fast‑paced action

Compare

The Verdict

AI-generated from listing data

Payday 2 offers deep heist‑focused tactical co‑op with strong narrative but higher solo difficulty, while Borderlands 2 delivers massive loot variety, humor, and broader platform support at a higher price.

Key differences

  • •Core focus: heist planning and stealth (Payday 2) vs. loot‑shooting sandbox (Borderlands 2).
  • •Weapon variety: fixed gear customization (Payday 2) vs. procedurally generated 4 million weapons (Borderlands 2).
  • •Art style & tone: gritty modern crime (Payday 2) vs. cel‑shaded sci‑fi comedy (Borderlands 2).
  • •Platform features: Payday 2 lacks split‑screen; Borderlands 2 includes split‑screen co‑op.
  • •Price: Payday 2 costs $19.99; Borderlands 2 costs $39.99.
DimensionWinner

Gameplay & fun factor

Borderlands 2’s massive weapon pool and humor create constantly fresh combat, whereas Payday 2’s fun hinges on coordinated heists.

Borderlands 2

Platform availability

Borderlands 2 supports split‑screen co‑op; Payday 2 does not, giving Borderlands 2 broader local‑multiplayer options.

Borderlands 2

Price & value

Payday 2 is $19.99 versus Borderlands 2 at $39.99, offering lower upfront cost.

Payday 2

Multiplayer / co‑op

Both support four‑player online co‑op; Borderlands 2 adds split‑screen, but core online experience is comparable.

Tie

Content & replayability

Borderlands 2’s procedural weapons, side quests, and random events give higher replay value than Payday 2’s DLC‑heavy heists.

Borderlands 2

Difficulty & accessibility

Payday 2 can be very hard solo, but its skill tree offers clear progression; Borderlands 2’s grind can feel uneven.

Payday 2

Graphics & performance

Payday 2 uses an older engine that may feel dated, but no performance issues are noted; Borderlands 2 may suffer on older consoles.

Payday 2

Choose Borderlands 2 if…

Players who prioritize weapon variety, humor, split‑screen co‑op, and broader replayability.

Choose Payday 2 if…

Players who love tactical heist planning, deep RPG skill trees, and want a cheaper game.

Common questions

Which game is cheaper?

Payday 2 costs $19.99; Borderlands 2 costs $39.99.

Can I play locally with friends on the same screen?

Only Borderlands 2 offers split‑screen co‑op; Payday 2 does not.

Which title has more replay value?

Borderlands 2, thanks to its procedurally generated 4 million weapons, random events, and side quests.