Myst III: Exile vs Obsidian
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Myst III: Exile returns players to the enigmatic universe of Myst, where a new island holds the secrets of a broken link between worlds. As the player, you must solve intricate environmental puzzles to restore balance and uncover the story behind the exile of a former Myst explorer. The game blends richly detailed pre-rendered graphics with immersive sound design, delivering a classic point‑and‑click adventure experience across multiple platforms. Its single‑player focus invites deep exploration and thoughtful problem‑solving for fans of mystery and fantasy storytelling.
Obsidian is a point‑and‑click adventure that thrusts players into a bizarre, science‑fiction thriller world where every choice matters. Solve intricate puzzles while unraveling a mysterious narrative that challenges your perception of reality. Set in 1997, this single‑player experience blends atmospheric storytelling with clever brain‑teasers, offering a hauntingly immersive journey for fans of classic adventure games.
- Stunning pre‑rendered graphics
- Engaging and varied puzzles
- Rich, immersive atmosphere
- Strong narrative continuity
- Engaging, atmospheric storytelling
- Varied and inventive puzzles
- High replay value due to multiple endings
- Beautiful hand‑drawn art style
- Occasional obscure puzzle logic
- Limited replayability after completion
- Outdated control scheme on newer platforms
- Occasional obscure puzzle solutions
- Limited save slots can force replay of sections
- Some dialogue pacing feels slow
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Myst III: Exile
View all →
A globe‑trotting mystery where ancient myths collide with modern intrigue
Alternatives to Obsidian
View all →
A sci‑fi point‑and‑click adventure where every decision can mean life or death
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataObsidian offers a cheaper, hand‑drawn adventure with multiple endings, while Myst III delivers higher‑resolution graphics and a conclusive Myst storyline at a higher price.
Key differences
- •Price: Obsidian $19.99 vs Myst III $49.99.
- •Graphics: Hand‑drawn art in Obsidian vs high‑resolution pre‑rendered 3D in Myst III.
- •Replayability: Obsidian’s branching endings vs Myst III’s limited post‑completion replay.
- •Platform spread: Both on PC/Mac, but Myst III also on PlayStation 2.
- •Narrative scope: Obsidian is standalone; Myst III concludes the Myst trilogy.
Gameplay & fun factor
Obsidian’s varied puzzles and branching story create more replay fun than Myst III’s linear conclusion.
Platform availability
Myst III adds PlayStation 2 support, while both share PC/Mac.
Price & value
Obsidian costs $19.99, offering comparable adventure content for less than half Myst III’s $49.99.
Multiplayer / co‑op
Both are single‑player only.
Content & replayability
Obsidian’s multiple endings and hidden collectibles boost replay versus Myst III’s limited replay after story end.
Difficulty & accessibility
Myst III includes an optional hint system without scaling difficulty, while Obsidian’s hints depend on difficulty settings.
Graphics & performance
Myst III’s high‑resolution textures and dynamic lighting surpass Obsidian’s hand‑drawn 2D visuals.
Choose Myst III: Exile if…
Players prioritizing cutting‑edge graphics and a definitive Myst storyline.
Choose Obsidian if…
Budget‑conscious players who value replayability and hand‑drawn art.
Common questions
Which game is cheaper?
Obsidian costs $19.99; Myst III costs $49.99.
Do both games have hint systems?
Yes. Obsidian’s hint system scales with difficulty; Myst III offers optional contextual hints.
Can I play either game on a console?
Myst III is also available on PlayStation 2; Obsidian is PC and Mac only.