Sonic Colors vs Super Mario All-Stars
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Sonic Colors is a platforming adventure starring Sonic the Hedgehog as he battles Dr. Eggman in an intergalactic amusement park. The game blends 3D third‑person runs with side‑scrolling sections and introduces Wisps, alien power‑ups that grant new abilities. Released worldwide for Wii and Nintendo DS in November 2010, the title offers both single‑player and multiplayer modes, appealing to younger gamers and families with its colorful visuals and accessible difficulty.
Super Mario All-Stars bundles the four iconic NES Mario titles—Super Mario Bros., Super Mario Bros. 2, Super Mario Bros. 3, and the previously unreleased Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels—enhanced with 16‑bit graphics, richer sound, and on‑cartridge save support. The collection also adds a new battle mode for Super Mario Bros. 3, giving players fresh multiplayer fun on the original Super NES hardware.
- Vibrant, eye‑catching visuals
- Innovative Wisp power‑up system
- Blend of 3D and side‑scrolling gameplay
- Family‑friendly difficulty curve
- All four classic games in one cartridge
- Improved 16‑bit visuals and audio
- Save feature adds convenience
- Includes previously unreleased Lost Levels
- Limited platform availability (Wii/DS only)
- Some level designs feel repetitive
- Multiplayer options are basic
- Only available on legacy SNES hardware
- No online multiplayer support
- Graphics, while upgraded, are still retro‑style
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Sonic Colors
View all →
Alternatives to Super Mario All-Stars
View all →No alternatives listed yet. Browse similar tools →
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataSonic Colors offers modern 3D/2D hybrid platforming on Wii/DS with vibrant visuals, while Super Mario All-Stars bundles four classic 16‑bit Mario titles for SNES with retro charm and a lower price.
Key differences
- •Platform: Sonic Colors runs on Wii and DS only; Mario All-Stars requires legacy SNES hardware.
- •Content scope: Sonic Colors is a single new game; Mario All-Stars includes four full classic games plus Lost Levels.
- •Graphics style: Sonic Colors uses contemporary 3D visuals; Mario All-Stars uses upgraded 16‑bit retro graphics.
- •Multiplayer: Sonic Colors offers basic mini‑games; Mario All-Stars adds split‑screen competitive mode for Super Mario Bros. 3.
- •Price: Sonic Colors MSRP $59.99; Mario All-Stars MSRP $39.99.
Gameplay & fun factor
Sonic Colors blends 3D and side‑scrolling with Wisp power‑ups, offering a fresh experience versus retro platforming.
Platform availability
Mario All-Stars runs on SNES, a single legacy console, while Sonic Colors is limited to Wii/DS only.
Price & value
Mario All-Stars costs $39.99 and includes four games, giving more content per dollar than Sonic Colors at $59.99.
Multiplayer / co‑op
Mario All-Stars provides split‑screen competitive mode; Sonic Colors only has basic multiplayer mini‑games.
Content & replayability
Four distinct Mario titles plus Lost Levels increase replay value compared to a single Sonic Colors campaign.
Difficulty & accessibility
Sonic Colors is marketed as family‑friendly with easy controls for younger players; Mario All-Stars retains original difficulty.
Graphics & performance
Sonic Colors features modern 3D visuals and vibrant colors; Mario All-Stars uses retro 16‑bit graphics.
Choose Sonic Colors if…
Buy Sonic Colors if you have a Wii or DS and want a modern, family‑friendly platformer with fresh mechanics.
Choose Super Mario All-Stars if…
Buy Super Mario All-Stars if you own an SNES and prefer classic Mario games with more content at a lower price.
Common questions
Which game offers more content for the price?
Super Mario All-Stars includes four full games plus Lost Levels for $39.99, whereas Sonic Colors is a single title at $59.99.
Do I need a specific console to play either game?
Yes. Sonic Colors requires a Wii or Nintendo DS; Super Mario All-Stars runs only on the Super Nintendo Entertainment System.
Which title is more suitable for younger children?
Sonic Colors is marketed as family‑friendly with easy controls and a gentle difficulty curve, while Mario All-Stars keeps the original, often harder, retro difficulty.