TNA Impact! vs WWE All Stars
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.

TNA Impact! brings the high‑octane action of the weekly TV show to your console, letting you battle as legends like Kurt Angle, AJ Styles, and Samoa Joe in the signature six‑sided ring. The game features a robust creation suite so you can design custom wrestlers with unique moves, looks, and entrance styles. Play solo career modes, challenge friends in split‑screen multiplayer, or dominate the arena with a full roster of over 20 TNA stars. With fast‑paced combat, authentic takedowns, and a variety of match types, TNA Impact! delivers the adrenaline‑pumping experience fans expect from Total Nonstop Action Wrestling.
WWE All Stars delivers fast‑paced, over‑the‑top wrestling action that pits classic icons like Hulk Hogan and Ultimate Warrior against today’s superstars such as John Cena and Triple H. The game’s exaggerated moves and colorful arenas capture the spirit of an arcade brawler while staying true to wrestling’s larger‑than‑life personalities. Up to four players can battle locally in split‑screen mode, using a simple combo system to pull off spectacular finishers. Available on PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, and PlayStation 2, it offers both single‑player story modes and chaotic multiplayer matches for fans of high‑energy sports combat.
- Large roster of authentic TNA talent
- Robust wrestler creation system
- Split‑screen multiplayer for couch co‑op
- Unique six‑sided ring adds fresh gameplay
- Huge mix of classic and modern wrestlers
- Exciting arcade‑style combat
- Local split‑screen for up to four players
- Simple controls suitable for newcomers
- Graphics are dated compared to modern titles
- Limited online features and matchmaking
- Career mode can feel repetitive after several playthroughs
- Limited online multiplayer options
- Graphics feel dated on newer consoles
- Roster lacks some recent WWE stars
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to TNA Impact!
View all →Alternatives to WWE All Stars
View all →
Control the action with interactive entrances and epic victory scenes.
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataBoth are one‑time $59.99 wrestling games with split‑screen couch co‑op, but WWE All Stars offers a broader, more varied roster and higher critic score, while TNA Impact! provides a unique six‑sided ring and deeper wrestler creation.
Key differences
- •Roster: TNA Impact! features over 20 authentic TNA stars; WWE All Stars mixes classic and modern WWE legends but omits recent stars.
- •Ring design: TNA Impact! uses a distinctive six‑sided ring; WWE All Stars uses standard arenas.
- •Critic reception: WWE All Stars scored 63/100 vs. TNA Impact!'s 53/100.
- •Platform reach: WWE All Stars is confirmed on PS3, Xbox 360, PS2; TNA Impact! platform not specified.
- •Creation depth: TNA Impact! offers detailed wrestler customization; WWE All Stars relies on simple two‑button combos.
Gameplay & fun factor
WWE All Stars' arcade style and exaggerated physics are praised, while TNA Impact! is noted as repetitive.
Platform availability
WWE All Stars lists PS3, Xbox 360, PS2; TNA Impact! platform not specified.
Price & value
Both cost $59.99 with one‑time purchase.
Multiplayer / co‑op
Both support up to four players split‑screen locally; online features limited for both.
Content & replayability
TNA Impact! includes a career mode tracking titles/rivalries and a robust creation system.
Difficulty & accessibility
WWE All Stars uses a simple two‑button combo system, making it easier for newcomers.
Graphics & performance
Both are described as having dated graphics on newer consoles.
Choose TNA Impact! if…
Fans who want deep wrestler creation and a unique six‑sided TNA experience.
Choose WWE All Stars if…
Players seeking a larger, mixed WWE roster, arcade‑style action, and broader console support.
Common questions
Do either of these games support online multiplayer?
Both have limited online features; TNA Impact! offers leaderboards, WWE All Stars has limited online multiplayer.
Which game has a higher critical reception?
WWE All Stars received a critic score of 63/100, compared to TNA Impact!'s 53/100.
Can I play these games on modern consoles?
WWE All Stars is listed for PS3, Xbox 360, and PS2; TNA Impact!'s platform is not specified, so compatibility is unclear.





