Twisted Metal: Black vs Twisted Metal III
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Twisted Metal: Black is a vehicle combat video game developed by Incognito Entertainment and published by Sony Computer Entertainment for the PlayStation 2, later made available on PlayStation 3 and PlayStation 4. Set in an alternate, darker universe, players battle across destructive arenas while pursuing a twisted storyline centered on a mission to kill Calypso. The game received a free online‑only update, Twisted Metal: Black Online, adding multiplayer‑only modes and extending its replay value. With a critic score of 90/100, it remains a benchmark for chaotic, story‑driven combat games.
Twisted Metal III is a 1998 vehicular combat game for the PlayStation where players drive armed vehicles in arena battles, aiming to destroy opponents and survive each round. The tournament is hosted by the mysterious Calypso, who grants a twisted wish to the winner. The sequel introduces new characters, fresh arenas, and a redesigned physics engine under the direction of 989 Studios. While it retains the series' chaotic combat, it received mixed reviews due to control changes and design shifts.
- Deep, gritty storyline
- Robust multiplayer options including split‑screen
- Free online‑only update expands content
- High critical acclaim
- Wide selection of new characters and vehicles
- Varied arena designs with interactive elements
- Local multiplayer supports up to four players
- Distinct wish mechanic adds narrative twist
- Graphics dated by modern standards
- Limited platform availability beyond PlayStation
- Steep learning curve for vehicle controls
- Control scheme felt clunky to many players
- Physics changes received mixed reactions
- Limited to original PlayStation hardware
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Twisted Metal: Black
View all →
Alternatives to Twisted Metal III
View all →
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataTwisted Metal: Black offers higher critical acclaim, lower price, and broader multiplayer options, while Twisted Metal III is pricier, has clunkier controls, and is limited to original PlayStation.
Key differences
- •Critic Score: 90/100 (Black) vs 60/100 (III).
- •Price: $19.99 (Black) vs $49.99 (III).
- •Multiplayer: Black adds online mode and split‑screen; III only split‑screen up to four on PS1.
- •Platform: Black runs on PS2/PS3/PS4; III limited to original PlayStation.
- •Graphics/Engine: Black’s dated graphics but newer engine; III’s physics changes received mixed reactions.
Gameplay & fun factor
Black’s gritty storyline and robust multiplayer earned a 90 critic score versus III’s mixed reception (60).
Platform availability
Black runs on PS2, PS3, PS4; III is limited to the original PlayStation.
Price & value
Black costs $19.99, less than half of III’s $49.99, offering more content for less money.
Multiplayer / co‑op
Black includes split‑screen, online‑only mode, and co‑op; III only supports local split‑screen up to four.
Content & replayability
Black adds free online update with new maps/weapons, increasing replay value beyond III’s static arenas.
Difficulty & accessibility
III’s simpler controls may be easier for newcomers, whereas Black has a steep learning curve.
Graphics & performance
III’s original PS1 graphics are less dated than Black’s already‑aged visuals on newer consoles.
Choose Twisted Metal: Black if…
Buyers seeking better reviews, cheaper price, modern console compatibility, and richer multiplayer.
Choose Twisted Metal III if…
Buyers who prefer original PS1 experience, want simpler controls, and don’t mind higher price.
Common questions
Which game is cheaper?
Twisted Metal: Black costs $19.99; Twisted Metal III costs $49.99.
Can I play online multiplayer?
Only Twisted Metal: Black offers an online‑only multiplayer mode; III is limited to local split‑screen.
Will the game run on my PS4?
Twisted Metal: Black supports PS2, PS3, and PS4; Twisted Metal III is limited to the original PlayStation.