All-Pro Football 2K8 vs Madden NFL 98
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
All-Pro Football 2K8 lets you assemble a squad of historic NFL greats—Rice, Unitas, Butkus, Singletary—and pit them against each other or combine them on a single team. The game emphasizes deep player creation, allowing you to design mercenary-style athletes with precise attributes. Play solo, compete online, or enjoy split‑screen battles on PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360. With realistic physics and detailed stats, the experience feels like a true football simulation for both casual fans and hardcore strategists.
Madden NFL 98 brings the excitement of professional football to the PC with John Madden's signature play‑calling expertise. The game features a full season, playoffs, and the Super Bowl, all presented in a TV‑style broadcast format with real‑time analysis. New for 1998 are advanced quarterback mechanics like lob passes and timing adjustments, plus a more instinctive AI that adapts as the match progresses. Build your own plays, trade them, and compete with both contemporary NFL teams and legendary squads from the past.
- Deep player creation tools
- Legendary NFL roster integration
- Robust split‑screen multiplayer
- Realistic physics and stats
- Deep quarterback mechanics with lob passes
- Robust AI that adapts during play
- Full season and playoff structure
- Ability to create and trade custom plays
- Limited platform availability (PS3, Xbox 360 only)
- Online matchmaking can be slow
- Graphics dated by modern standards
- PC graphics are dated by modern standards
- Limited online multiplayer options
- Learning curve for advanced QB controls
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to All-Pro Football 2K8
View all →
Lead your nation to World Cup glory in the ultimate football showdown.
Alternatives to Madden NFL 98
View all →
Classic 1993 NFL action with all teams, weather effects, and Chris Berman commentary.
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataMadden NFL 98 offers classic season play with deeper quarterback controls, while All‑Pro Football 2K8 focuses on extensive player creation and modern multiplayer options.
Key differences
- •QB‑focused mechanics vs. full custom athlete builder
- •1998 season roster with historic squads vs. mixed Hall‑of‑Fame legends
- •PC‑only (Madden) vs. console‑only (All‑Pro) platform support
- •Higher critic score (85) vs. lower (68)
- •Price difference: $49.99 vs. $59.99
Gameplay & fun factor
Madden’s lob passes, timing controls and adaptive AI give deeper on‑field strategy (Critic 85).
Platform availability
All‑Pro runs on PS3/Xbox 360; Madden is PC‑only, limiting choice.
Price & value
Madden costs $49.99, $10 cheaper than All‑Pro’s $59.99.
Multiplayer / co‑op
All‑Pro supports up to four‑player split‑screen and online ranked play; Madden limited to split‑screen only.
Content & replayability
Full 1998 NFL season plus historic squads offers a complete league experience.
Difficulty & accessibility
All‑Pro’s player creation and standard controls are easier for newcomers; Madden’s advanced QB controls have a steeper learning curve.
Graphics & performance
Both are described as dated by modern standards; no specific performance data to differentiate.
Choose All-Pro Football 2K8 if…
Players who prioritize custom rosters, online play, and console gaming.
Choose Madden NFL 98 if…
Fans who want a full season NFL simulation with deep QB mechanics on PC.
Common questions
Which game is cheaper?
Madden NFL 98 costs $49.99; All‑Pro Football 2K8 costs $59.99.
Can I play online with friends?
All‑Pro offers online ranked and casual modes; Madden only supports local split‑screen.
What platforms can I use?
Madden is PC‑only; All‑Pro runs on PS3 and Xbox 360.