All-Star Baseball 2004 vs All-Star Baseball 2005
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.


All-Star Baseball 2004 is the 2004 installment in Acclaim's long-running baseball series, released for PlayStation 2. It brings more than 80 new features and improvements over its predecessor, with the franchise mode receiving the most attention for its added depth and customization options. The game keeps the familiar button layout for swinging, bunting, stealing, and fielding, but updates the batting cursor's outline and introduces a new bunt mechanic where a large arrow on the ground replaces cursor aiming. Fielding also gets a subtle change with the ball cursor shifting color, and the game supports up to four players in split-screen play.
All-Star Baseball 2005 brings the excitement of Major League Baseball to the PlayStation 2 with realistic player stats, authentic stadiums, and the iconic cover star Derek Jeter. The game offers a variety of modes, from quick exhibition matches to full season management, letting you build and control your own franchise. Take advantage of expansion options that let you add cities like Mexico City and Puerto Rico, and enjoy multiplayer split‑screen action with friends for a true backyard baseball experience.
- Over 80 new features and improvements
- Deeper, more customizable franchise mode
- Supports four players in split-screen
- Accessible, familiar controls
- Deep franchise management
- Authentic MLB rosters and stadiums
- Split‑screen multiplayer support
- Robust customization options
- Bunting mechanic gives players limited aim precision
- Changes are incremental relative to the series' core gameplay
- Only available on PlayStation 2
- Graphics dated by modern standards
- Limited online functionality
- AI can be inconsistent in clutch situations
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to All-Star Baseball 2004
View all →
Experience authentic MLB action with deep team management and split‑screen fun.
Alternatives to All-Star Baseball 2005
View all →
Acclaim's 2004 baseball sim on PlayStation 2 with a deeper franchise mode and reworked bunting controls.
