Band Hero vs Guitar Hero 5
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Band Hero brings the popular Guitar Hero gameplay to a pop‑rock focused setlist, letting players jam to Top 40 hits across multiple consoles. The game supports lead guitar, bass, drums, and vocals with drop‑in/drop‑out play and in‑song instrument switching for a seamless party experience. The console versions use instrument‑shaped controllers while the DS version offers a Guitar Grip or Drum Skin, and features avatars of Taylor Swift, Adam Levine, and No Doubt for added visual flair.
Designed for both casual parties and competitive players, it offers a variety of challenges, Rockfest modes, and online multiplayer while letting players create avatars and customize instruments. The title received strong reviews for its accessibility and social features, despite a mixed reception to its broad setlist.
- Full‑band support with all four instrument types
- Drop‑in/drop‑out lets anyone join mid‑song
- Popular pop‑rock tracklist appeals to teens
- Avatar cameos add visual fun
- Easy drop‑in/out gameplay for spontaneous sessions
- Robust song library with 85 tracks
- Full compatibility with existing instrument controllers
- Strong online and local multiplayer options
- Only 65 songs, fewer than Guitar Hero 5
- Mixed reviews on depth for hardcore players
- No ongoing DLC after launch
- Setlist considered too broad by some fans
- Kurt Cobain avatar can be used on any song, causing controversy
- Sales were lower than previous installment
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Band Hero
View all →
Alternatives to Guitar Hero 5
View all →
Rock out as Aerosmith from garage to stardom in this guitar‑hero adventure.
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataBand Hero offers a pop‑rock focused, family‑friendly experience with fewer songs, while Guitar Hero 5 provides a larger, more diverse setlist, online play, and higher critic scores.
Key differences
- •Song count: 65 (Band Hero) vs 85 (Guitar Hero 5).
- •Online multiplayer: only Guitar Hero 5 supports it.
- •Age rating: ESRB E10+ (Band Hero) vs ESRB T (Guitar Hero 5).
- •Platform spread: Band Hero includes a Nintendo DS version; Guitar Hero 5 does not list DS.
- •Critic score: 76/100 (Band Hero) vs 81/100 (Guitar Hero 5).
Gameplay & fun factor
Both have drop‑in/out, but Guitar Hero 5’s larger song list and Rockfest mode add more variety.
Platform availability
Band Hero runs on PS2, PS3, Xbox 360, Wii, and DS; Guitar Hero 5’s platforms not specified for DS.
Pricing & value
Same $59.99 price, but Guitar Hero 5 offers 20 more songs and higher critic score.
Multiplayer / co‑op
Guitar Hero 5 adds online multiplayer and co‑op modes; Band Hero is limited to local split‑screen.
Content & replayability
85 tracks on Guitar Hero 5 vs 65 on Band Hero, plus user‑created tracks via GHTunes.
Difficulty & accessibility
Band Hero’s ESRB E10+ rating makes it more suitable for younger or casual players.
Graphics & performance
No specific graphics or performance data provided for either title.
Choose Band Hero if…
You’re a teen or parent seeking a pop‑focused, family‑friendly game with DS support.
Choose Guitar Hero 5 if…
You want a broader rock catalog, online play, and higher critical acclaim.
Common questions
Do both games cost the same?
Yes, each has an MSRP of $59.99.
Which game has more songs?
Guitar Hero 5 includes 85 songs; Band Hero includes 65 songs.
Can I play online with friends?
Only Guitar Hero 5 offers online multiplayer; Band Hero is limited to local split‑screen.