Dark Souls vs Dark Souls II
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Dark Souls is an action role-playing game developed by FromSoftware and published by Bandai Namco Entertainment. Set in a dark, medieval fantasy world, players control the Chosen Undead, navigating hostile environments filled with dangerous enemies, formidable bosses, and deep lore. Renowned for its punishing difficulty and intricate level design, the game requires careful management of combat, stamina, and resources. Players can experience the world through single-player exploration or utilize unique multiplayer components to leave messages, summon allies, or invade other worlds.
Dark Souls II is an action role‑playing game set in the fallen kingdom of Drangleic, where players assume the role of the Bearer of the Curse. Explore a dark, interconnected world filled with challenging enemies and epic boss encounters while managing stamina and timing. The game offers flexible character progression, dual‑wielding options, and both single‑player and online multiplayer modes, including co‑operative play. Its online servers were active until March 31st, 2024.
- Deep and rewarding combat mechanics
- Masterclass in intricate, interconnected level design
- Rich, haunting atmospheric world and lore
- Innovative asynchronous multiplayer features
- Deep, rewarding combat system
- Extensive character customization
- Rich, interconnected world design
- Robust online co‑op and PvP options
- Extremely punishing difficulty can frustrate some players
- Cryptic progression systems require careful attention or outside guides
- Steep learning curve for newcomers to the action RPG genre
- High difficulty may deter newcomers
- Servers shut down, limiting online features
- Occasional performance issues on PC
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Dark Souls
View all →
Alternatives to Dark Souls II
View all →
Explore shattered realms to free Castle Britannia from the Guardian’s blackrock spell
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataDark Souls offers the higher critic score and lower price, making it the safer default choice, while Dark Souls II adds more character customization and a larger world at a higher cost.
Key differences
- •Price: Dark Souls $39.99 vs Dark Souls II $59.99.
- •Character customization: Dark Souls II features a flexible class system and dual‑wielding options; Dark Souls has a single “Chosen Undead” build.
- •World design: Dark Souls II emphasizes an interconnected map with backtracking; Dark Souls focuses on a linear but intricately linked level layout.
- •Online support: Dark Souls II servers are shut down, limiting multiplayer; Dark Souls still retains its asynchronous multiplayer features.
- •Critic scores: Dark Souls 91/100, Dark Souls II 90/100.
Pricing & value
Dark Souls costs $39.99, $20 cheaper than Dark Souls II, giving better value for the same core experience.
Gameplay & fun factor
Both deliver deep, timing‑based combat praised by critics; differences are stylistic rather than quality‑based.
Multiplayer / co‑op
Dark Souls retains its asynchronous multiplayer; Dark Souls II’s servers are shut down, limiting online play.
Content & replayability
Dark Souls II adds a flexible class system, dual‑wielding, and a larger interconnected world for more build variety.
Difficulty & accessibility
Both are hard, but Dark Souls’ difficulty is well‑documented and supported by community guides; Dark Souls II’s higher difficulty may deter newcomers.
Graphics & performance
Dark Souls II notes occasional PC performance issues; Dark Souls has no listed performance problems.
Platform availability
Both are PC titles with similar platform reach; no differing platform data provided.
Choose Dark Souls if…
Buyers seeking the best critic rating, lower cost, and functional multiplayer.
Choose Dark Souls II if…
Players who want deeper customization, a bigger world, and can afford the higher price.
Common questions
Which game is cheaper?
Dark Souls is $39.99; Dark Souls II is $59.99.
Can I still play online multiplayer?
Dark Souls supports its asynchronous multiplayer; Dark Souls II servers are shut down, limiting online features.
Which offers more character build options?
Dark Souls II provides a flexible class system and dual‑wielding, giving more build variety than Dark Souls.