MyDesigns vs Sellfy
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
MyDesigns is an all-in-one print-on-demand and digital product management platform for Etsy, Shopify, WooCommerce, and TikTok Shop sellers. It combines bulk product creation, mockups, AI-generated listings, multi-platform publishing, fulfillment, and an AI agent called Scout that finds in-demand products and creates original versions for your catalog.
Sellfy is an ecommerce platform built for content creators and small businesses that want to launch an online store without coding. It supports selling digital downloads, physical products, print-on-demand merchandise, and recurring subscriptions from one storefront. The platform emphasizes zero transaction fees on sales and a drag-and-drop store builder, and reports more than 75,000 creators have collectively earned over $165 million through the platform.
MyDesigns offers a free plan plus three paid tiers—Starter at $19.99/month, Pro at $39.99/month, and Pro Plus at $79.99/month—with yearly billing available.
- Bulk product creation: launch up to 120 products in one batch on Pro Plus
- Scout AI finds products with real sales demand and generates original designs
- Publishes to Etsy, Shopify, WooCommerce, and TikTok Shop from one dashboard
- Includes AI-powered mockups, SEO listings, and background removal
- Zero transaction fees on sales within your plan's revenue threshold
- Combines digital, physical, print-on-demand, and subscription sales in one platform
- 14-day free trial with no credit card required
- Simple enough for creators without technical or design skills
- Free plan has no AI credits and only allows 4 products at a time
- Scout AI is only available on Pro and Pro Plus plans
- Credit system can be complex; AI actions consume credits and extra credit blocks are needed for daily Scout use
- Unused credits roll over only up to 3 months and are not refunded as cash
- A 2% fee applies to sales that exceed your plan's revenue threshold unless you upgrade
- Less customizable design system than dedicated store builders like Shopify
- File size limits scale with plan tier, which can matter for large digital products
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to MyDesigns
View all →
Alternatives to Sellfy
View all →
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataMyDesigns excels for high‑volume POD and digital sellers needing AI‑driven bulk creation, while Sellfy is a simpler all‑in‑one storefront for creators who prioritize zero transaction fees and basic e‑commerce features.
Key differences
- •MyDesigns offers AI‑powered bulk product creation (up to 120 items) and automated listings; Sellfy does not.
- •MyDesigns charges transaction fees (3‑6%) on its own store sales; Sellfy charges zero fees up to a revenue threshold, then 2%.
- •MyDesigns integrates directly with Etsy, Shopify, WooCommerce, TikTok Shop; Sellfy only integrates PayPal, Stripe, Printful.
- •MyDesigns uses a credit‑based AI usage model with rollover limits; Sellfy has a flat subscription with no credit system.
- •MyDesigns provides built‑in AI mockup, background removal, and SEO generation; Sellfy focuses on store builder and basic marketing tools.
Pricing & value
Sellfy has a flat subscription and zero transaction fees up to its plan limit, while MyDesigns adds 3‑6% fees and credit purchases.
Ease of use / learning curve
Sellfy’s drag‑and‑drop store builder is described as simple for non‑technical creators; MyDesigns involves credit management and AI setup.
Features & depth
MyDesigns provides AI design generation, bulk mockups, auto‑SEO, and multi‑channel publishing, far beyond Sellfy’s basic store tools.
Integrations & ecosystem
MyDesigns connects to Etsy, Shopify, WooCommerce, TikTok Shop and its own marketplace; Sellfy only lists PayPal, Stripe, Printful.
Scalability
MyDesigns can launch up to 120 products per batch, supporting rapid scaling; Sellfy lacks bulk creation capabilities.
Support
Both offer standard support (MyDesigns unspecified, Sellfy email/help‑center); no clear superiority in facts.
Security & privacy
No specific security or privacy details provided for either product.
Choose MyDesigns if…
High‑volume POD or digital sellers who need AI‑driven bulk creation and multi‑channel publishing.
Choose Sellfy if…
Solo creators or small businesses wanting a simple storefront with zero transaction fees up to a revenue cap.
Common questions
Which platform is cheaper for a seller who makes few sales?
Sellfy is cheaper because it has no transaction fees up to its plan’s revenue threshold and no credit purchases, whereas MyDesigns adds 3‑6% fees and may require credit blocks.
Can I automatically list products on Etsy and Shopify?
Yes, MyDesigns publishes to Etsy, Shopify, WooCommerce, and TikTok Shop from one dashboard; Sellfy does not offer direct multi‑channel listing.
Do I need technical skills to create product designs?
MyDesigns provides AI tools (Scout, Dream, Vision) that generate designs and listings automatically; Sellfy relies on you uploading assets and offers a simple store builder.