Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II vs The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Rose Tattoo
Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.
Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II lets players step into the shoes of the legendary detective and Dr. Watson to unravel three distinct, stand‑alone cases set in 1880s London. Each investigation blends narrative storytelling with point‑and‑click exploration, requiring careful note‑taking, clue gathering, and deduction to reach the correct solution. The game preserves the classic FMV style of the original series while delivering fresh puzzles and period‑accurate atmosphere. Designed for Mac, it offers a single‑player experience that challenges both newcomers and veteran mystery fans alike.
In October 1889 a powerful new explosive formula vanishes from the Ministry of Defense, prompting Mycroft Holmes to launch a secret inquiry. After a devastating explosion injures Mycroft, Sherlock, drawn out of retirement by Dr. Watson’s probing question, returns to 221B Baker Street to investigate the true cause. The game lets players explore 50 meticulously crafted Victorian London locations and interact with 90 uniquely costumed characters, delivering a point‑and‑click thriller that blends classic deduction with atmospheric storytelling.
- Rich, atmospheric Victorian setting
- Three distinct, well‑written cases
- Full‑motion video adds cinematic flair
- Deep clue‑tracking system
- Immersive Victorian atmosphere
- Large variety of characters and locations
- Complex, rewarding puzzles
- Strong narrative with multiple endings
- Interface feels dated compared to modern adventure games
- Limited replay value after solving all cases
- Mac version may require compatibility tweaks on newer OS releases
- dated graphics by modern standards
- Limited save system
- Occasional dialogue dead‑ends
More alternatives & similar tools
Alternatives to Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II
View all →
Solve a Victorian murder in a classic point‑and‑click adventure.
Solve Victorian mysteries in a sprawling 50‑location adventure.
Solve a murder mystery in Victorian London with Holmes and Watson
Alternatives to The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Rose Tattoo
View all →
Solve ancient riddles and deadly traps as Sherlock Holmes in a mummy mystery.
Solve three gripping Victorian mysteries with Holmes and Watson.
The Verdict
AI-generated from listing dataBoth games offer Victorian detective stories, but Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II gives three tightly‑crafted FMV cases, while The Lost Files provides a larger world with 50 locations and more puzzles.
Key differences
- •Case count vs. world size – A has 3 self‑contained mysteries; B features one mystery across 50 locations.
- •Presentation style – A uses full‑motion video actors; B uses classic point‑and‑click graphics.
- •Puzzle complexity – B emphasizes intricate item‑combination puzzles; A focuses on clue‑gathering and interview dialogue.
- •Replay value – A’s multiple solution paths are limited after solving; B offers alternate endings and hidden story details.
- •Known price – B is listed at $19.99; A’s price is not specified.
Gameplay & fun factor
B provides a larger variety of locations, characters, and puzzles, delivering broader interactive play.
Platform availability
A explicitly mentions a native Mac version; B’s platform details are not provided.
Price & value
B’s price is known ($19.99); A’s price is unspecified, making B the clearer value proposition.
Multiplayer / co‑op
Both are single‑player experiences.
Content & replayability
B offers a sprawling 50‑location map and multiple endings, giving more content to revisit.
Difficulty & accessibility
A’s FMV dialogue‑driven investigation is generally less mechanically demanding than B’s complex puzzles.
Graphics & performance
A uses full‑motion video actors and runs natively on modern Mac hardware; B’s graphics are dated but no performance data given.
Choose Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II if…
Ideal for players who prefer narrative‑driven FMV mysteries with minimal puzzle friction.
Choose The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Rose Tattoo if…
Best for gamers wanting a larger Victorian world, many characters, and challenging puzzles.
Common questions
Which game is cheaper?
The Lost Files lists a price of $19.99; Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II does not disclose its price.
Do either of the games support modern operating systems?
Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II runs natively on modern Mac hardware; compatibility for The Lost Files is not specified.
How much replay value does each title offer?
A provides multiple solution paths but limited after solving all three cases; B includes alternate endings and hidden story details for greater replayability.