FindAlternative
Back to Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments vs The Testament of Sherlock Holmes

Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.

Compare
Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments
Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & PunishmentsSolve six morally complex Victorian mysteries as Sherlock Holmes.
The Testament of Sherlock Holmes
The Testament of Sherlock HolmesUnravel a dark London mystery where Sherlock becomes the prime suspect.
Overview
Description

Step into the shoes of the legendary detective in 1894‑1895 London and investigate six diverse cases ranging from murder to a vanished train. Each investigation lets you examine crime scenes, interrogate witnesses, and piece together clues in a richly detailed world.\nYour choices matter: after uncovering the truth you decide between justice and mercy, shaping Holmes' reputation and the story’s outcome. The game blends classic adventure puzzles with moral decision‑making for a deep, narrative‑driven experience.

Set in 1898 London, you step into Sherlock Holmes' shoes as he fights to clear his name against accusations of theft, fraud, and murder. The game blends classic point‑and‑click adventure with a new deduction system, letting you inspect clues, reenact crimes, and interrogate suspects in a richly detailed Victorian world. The mature storyline challenges your wits at every turn, offering open‑ended investigations where every decision shapes the outcome. With immersive environments and a focus on logical reasoning, it delivers a deep, narrative‑driven experience for fans of detective fiction.

Pricing
Paid (One-time)
Paid (One-time)
Category
Puzzle Adventure
Story-Rich
Best for
Fans of story-driven detective games
Fans of detective adventure puzzles
Specifications
General
msrp
$59.99
—
release date
2014-09-29
2012-09-25
Specifications
developer
Frogwares
Frogwares
publisher
Focus Entertainment, Maximum Games
Atlus, Focus Entertainment
age rating
PEGI 16, ESRB M
PEGI 16, ESRB M
multiplayer
Single player
Single player
critic score
75/100
76/100+1%
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • Engaging moral decision system
  • Rich atmospheric Victorian setting
  • Varied case types keep gameplay fresh
  • Strong voice acting and narrative
  • Deep, mature storyline
  • Innovative deduction mechanics
  • Richly detailed Victorian environments
  • Fully voiced characters
Cons
  • Linear case progression limits replayability
  • Occasional clunky controls on console
  • Some puzzles can feel overly obscure
  • Linear progression can limit replayability
  • Occasional pacing issues in dialogue sections
  • Graphics show their age on modern hardware
Community & Metrics
Upvotes
0
0
User rating
Not enough data
Not enough data

More alternatives & similar tools

Alternatives to Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments

View all →
Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II
Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Vol. II

Solve three gripping Victorian mysteries with Holmes and Watson.

Compare
Sherlock Holmes: The Silver Earring
Sherlock Holmes: The Silver Earring

Solve a murder mystery in Victorian London with Holmes and Watson

Compare
The Testament of Sherlock Holmes
The Testament of Sherlock Holmes

Unravel a dark London mystery where Sherlock becomes the prime suspect.

Compare
The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Serrated Scalpel
The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Serrated Scalpel

Solve a Victorian murder in a classic point‑and‑click adventure.

Compare

Alternatives to The Testament of Sherlock Holmes

View all →
Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments
Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments

Solve six morally complex Victorian mysteries as Sherlock Holmes.

Compare

The Verdict

AI-generated from listing data

Both games offer story-driven Sherlock Holmes detective experiences, but Crimes & Punishments adds moral choices and varied case types, while Testament focuses on a single, darker narrative with deeper deduction mechanics.

Key differences

  • •Crimes & Punishments includes a moral decision system affecting reputation; Testament has a branching story but no explicit moral system.
  • •Crimes & Punishments offers six separate cases; Testament centers on one main mystery.
  • •Deduction mechanics: Testament emphasizes a dedicated deduction system; Crimes & Punishments uses broader forensic analysis and lock‑picking puzzles.
  • •Release dates: Crimes & Punishments (2014) is newer than Testament (2012), potentially affecting polish and bug fixes.
  • •Pricing detail: Crimes & Punishments lists an MSRP of $59.99; Testament’s price is not specified.
DimensionWinner

Gameplay & fun factor

Crimes & Punishments offers varied case types, moral choices, and multiple puzzle styles, giving broader gameplay variety.

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments

Platform availability

Both are single‑player games; no platform list provided, so no clear advantage.

Tie

Pricing & value

A lists $59.99 MSRP; B’s price is not specified, preventing a direct value comparison.

Tie

Multiplayer / co‑op

Both are single‑player only.

Tie

Content & replayability

Six distinct cases in Crimes & Punishments vs. a single main mystery in Testament, offering more content.

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments

Difficulty & accessibility

Both note occasional obscure puzzles or pacing issues, but no concrete difficulty metrics are given.

Tie

Graphics & performance

Testament explicitly notes graphics show their age; Crimes & Punishments has no graphics criticism listed.

The Testament of Sherlock Holmes

Choose Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments if…

Buy if you want multiple cases, moral choices, and broader puzzle variety.

Choose The Testament of Sherlock Holmes if…

Buy if you prefer a single, darker story with deeper deduction mechanics.

Common questions

Which game has more content to play through?

Crimes & Punishments features six separate cases; Testament focuses on one main mystery.

Do either of the games support multiplayer?

Both are single‑player only.

Is there a price difference between the two?

Crimes & Punishments lists an MSRP of $59.99; Testament’s price is not specified in the provided data.