FindAlternative
Back to The Immortal

The Immortal vs Trial by Magic

Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, ratings, and alternatives.

Compare
The Immortal
The ImmortalA wizard’s trial‑and‑error quest through eight deadly isometric dungeons
Trial by Magic
Trial by MagicSolve the ultimate riddle and claim unimaginable wealth in a classic fantasy adventure.
Overview
Description

The Immortal is an isometric action‑adventure RPG where you play as an unnamed wizard searching for the missing mentor Mordamir. Each of the eight levels is a puzzle of traps and hazards that must be learned through repeated death and careful observation. The game blends classic fantasy atmosphere with a relentless trial‑and‑error gameplay loop, rewarding players with hidden graphics and secrets as they master each level’s patterns.

Trial by Magic invites players into a mysterious realm crafted by the enigmatic Trialmaster. As a lone adventurer, you must navigate treacherous puzzles, confront magical threats, and uncover the secrets of the Trial to survive. Set in a richly detailed fantasy world, the game blends role‑playing depth with brain‑teasing challenges. Every decision shapes your journey, and only the cleverest will reap the promised riches.

Pricing
Paid (One-time)
Paid (One-time)
Category
Action RPG
Puzzle Adventure
Best for
Retro RPG and puzzle enthusiasts
RPG enthusiasts and puzzle lovers
Specifications
Specifications
developer
Sandcastle Productions
Silver Lightning Software
publisher
Electronic Arts Victor, Electronic Arts, The Hit Squad, Tec Toy, Ocean Software
Merit Software
age rating
PEGI 12, ESRB T
ESRB E
multiplayer
Single player
Single player
General
release date
1990-11-01
1995-12-31
msrp
$19.99
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • Deeply rewarding trap memorization
  • Atmospheric fantasy narrative
  • Distinctive isometric pixel art
  • High replay value for challenge seekers
  • Engaging riddle mechanics that reward logical thinking
  • Rich fantasy world with detailed lore
  • Turn‑based combat adds strategic depth
  • Atmospheric pixel art and music create immersion
Cons
  • Very high difficulty may frustrate casual players
  • Limited content beyond eight levels
  • Lacks modern quality‑of‑life features
  • Dated graphics may not appeal to modern gamers
  • Puzzle difficulty spikes can be frustrating
  • Limited replayability after solving the main riddle
Community & Metrics
Upvotes
0
0
User rating
Not enough data
Not enough data

More alternatives & similar tools

Alternatives to The Immortal

View all →
Dungeon Hack
Dungeon Hack

Endlessly fresh dungeons with random puzzles and monsters

Compare
Trial by Magic
Trial by Magic

Solve the ultimate riddle and claim unimaginable wealth in a classic fantasy adventure.

Compare
Nemesis: The Wizardry Adventure
Nemesis: The Wizardry Adventure

Explore a haunted fantasy world where ancient talismans hold deadly power

Compare
Fatal Labyrinth
Fatal Labyrinth

Rescue the Holy Goblet and save the world from darkness

Compare

Alternatives to Trial by Magic

View all →
Dungeon Hack
Dungeon Hack

Endlessly fresh dungeons with random puzzles and monsters

Compare
Nemesis: The Wizardry Adventure
Nemesis: The Wizardry Adventure

Explore a haunted fantasy world where ancient talismans hold deadly power

Compare
Planescape: Torment
Planescape: Torment

A philosophical RPG where death is just the beginning.

Compare
The Immortal
The Immortal

A wizard’s trial‑and‑error quest through eight deadly isometric dungeons

Compare

The Verdict

AI-generated from listing data

Trial by Magic offers a richer story and turn‑based combat with moderate difficulty, while The Immortal delivers a short, ultra‑hard puzzle‑run with high replay value.

Key differences

  • Story depth: Trial by Magic includes branching lore and multiple difficulty tiers; The Immortal focuses on a simple wizard narrative.
  • Combat vs. pure puzzle: Trial by Magic adds turn‑based combat; The Immortal is pure trap‑memory puzzles.
  • Difficulty level: Trial by Magic has spikes but is accessible; The Immortal is consistently very high difficulty.
  • Replayability: Trial by Magic’s replay value drops after solving the main riddle; The Immortal encourages repeated runs for mastery.
  • Art style: Trial by Magic uses hand‑drawn pixel art; The Immortal uses minimalist isometric pixel art.
DimensionWinner

Gameplay & fun factor

Trial by Magic mixes puzzles, combat, and branching story, offering broader gameplay than The Immortal’s pure trap puzzles.

Trial by Magic

Platform availability

No platform information is provided for either title.

Tie

Price & value

Both are one‑time paid games; only Trial by Magic’s price ($19.99) is disclosed.

Tie

Multiplayer / co‑op

Both are single‑player only.

Tie

Content & replayability

The Immortal’s high‑difficulty loops give strong replay value; Trial by Magic’s replayability is limited after the main riddle.

The Immortal

Difficulty & accessibility

Trial by Magic offers multiple difficulty tiers and occasional spikes, whereas The Immortal is very high difficulty throughout.

Trial by Magic

Graphics & performance

Both use pixel‑art styles; one is hand‑drawn, the other is minimalist isometric, no performance data given.

Tie

Choose The Immortal if…

Players craving a short, ultra‑hard puzzle challenge with high replay loops.

Choose Trial by Magic if…

RPG fans who want story, combat, and moderate difficulty.

Common questions

What is the price of each game?

Trial by Magic costs $19.99; The Immortal’s price is not specified.

Which game is more suitable for casual players?

Trial by Magic, because it offers multiple difficulty tiers and less relentless difficulty than The Immortal.

Do either of the games support multiplayer?

No. Both are single‑player experiences.